Little Italy Pizza in Winder

Hands down my favorite pizzeria! Their sauce is addictive, their version of a white pizza is amazeballs, but my personal must-have is their Buffalo Chicken pizza. Go get'cha some today!

I love their food. However, they never seem to answer the phone. I called this evening three times, no answer. This has happened numerous times resulting in my business going to Marco's Pizza. Not as tasty, but I don't have to sit and wait to place my order and for the food to be prepared. How does anyone stay in business if you avoid business?

Great pizza.....medium $

The food was all cold the sub that we ordered was supposed to be hot it was ice cold. Called and talked to the manager and he called me a liar. SO if you want cold pizza and subs this is your place. If you want hot food go some place else

This place has the best meatballs, their subs are awesome, and their pizza is good too. Their spaghetti and meatballs is by the best around. I’ve eaten there ever since moving to Winder and the family loves it

Walked in Friday night at dinner rush... everything was cooked perfectly, pizza was hot and staff very friendly. Loki made our pizza and it was awesome.

It was very busy tonight as it was Winder's spooktacular. The was a wait but the food was hot and tasted great. The prices were very reasonable too. I will definitely be going back again!

The best Italian around. Wonderful!!

The best New York style pizza I've had in Georgia. The stromboli and subs are also great. Always consistently high quality food in the 10 years I've been going there.

Some of the best pizza I have ever ate. The pizza by the Slice are huge. Really recommend this place.

I called in my order knowing that'll be busy. As I ordered I was rudly cut off and had to repeat my order x2. When I arrived and tried to pick up my order, it was made incorrectly. I ordered their cheese pizza with black olives and some how got a meat lovers. They offered to remake it but that's 20-30mins. No discount or insentive was offered for their mistake. Had to settle for little ceasers, some how they get it right.

Bought sub from there and pizza it was terrible bought same thing in and Athens it was great to

Had a "Little Italy Special" large pizza. On point as usual. Crust was perfect. Plenty of toppings. If you can, eat there. Doesn't travel well.

Don't like leaving negative reviews, but this place is horrible.. I can't understand how it has a 4.4 review!! I ordered a takeout 18 inch and a 16 inch based off of the positive reviews, man was that a mistake. The crust was tough and chewy, the sauce was watery..the menu says "fresh" garlic and "fresh" mushrooms...neither of them were fresh.. both from a jar and or can. After shockingly paying $53.00, I kept a positive attitude, expecting the great New York style pizza, what a huge disappointment.. Because of the price that I paid for the pizzas, we tried to eat some of it anyway.. but just could not force it down. Total waste of money, not to mention the gift it gave us of holding the toilet down.I've had great pizza before, and this is far from it.. I understand maybe having an off day., but this was just terrible

Usually nothing but good things to day about little Italy. The past few times have not been good at all. Pizza was doughy.

This is the first time I've been here. I called in an order to go and the lady that answered the phone was so nice and patient, very helpful. The salad bar is small but everything was really clean and fresh. The food was AMAZING! I got 2 pizza slices, baked ziti, stuffed shells, and veal parmesan sub. We were all very satisfied, very happy! We will definitely be going there again!

Outstanding! Best pizza period!

This is one of the best restaurants in Winder!!! The food is amazing!!!The staff is very nice and friendly!!! I ordered the Calzone with meatballs. They don't charge extra for a side of sauce. It was so good I ate the whole thing!!! It was fresh and made to order!!! No frozen out of the card board box pizza or Calzone here!!!! It was a Saturday night and it was busy and still got my order in less than 10 minutes!!! The price is right too!!! Definitely will be back very soon!!! Yum!!!

Walked in before 9pm just a few minutes ago and girl taking orders at front was incredibly rude and told us and the lady behind us their hours are until 10 but they usually like to close at 9 when they are slow and stared at us like she was waiting for us to leave. I asked if I could make a Hawaiian and she says "No" so I then just made a custom pizza order and she still didnt hear the 3 toppings I asked for. When she asked us if we wanted our receipt I asked if it was itemized and she stared blankly and said "I mean one is yours and one is ours" and I had to explain I was asking if it had each item we hard ordered on it. Not once did she smile or seem happy to be working. The food was good and the only reason I'm giving even two stars. A person's attitude can ruin an entire dinner!!!

Calzone portion size gets smaller and smaller. The taste is good but it’s very expensive for the size of the calzone. They used to make them much larger.

If you are visiting fort yargo This is a great place to put on the calories you just burned off. Forgot the name of the style of pizza I ate but it was similar to a Chicago style deep dish. It was way too much to eat in one setting for 3 people. Next time in Winder hit this place up

Omg!! I found my slice of heaven/ jersey here. Thank you for making delicious pizzas that remind me of home.

The staff was young and some of them untrained in how to work in a restaurant setting (hello, wash your hands), but the pizza cook actually tosses the dough, and quite well, so that got my respect. We had a Neapolitan meat lover's pizza (thin) and a stromboli and garlic bread. The pizza crust was just right, not paper thin, and had good chew. Not overly flavorful but didn't ruin the pizza with its own weird flavor like some places. The stromboli was not like I'm used to, it was like it was baked and then cut open, fillings added, and baked again. But it came out good. And the garlic bread was literally bread (good crusty bread too) not just another way to use pizza dough. Basically I liked this place. I'm tired of the national chain stores, this is a welcome break and I'll be back.

Nicole is an awesome employee. Great seeing her everytime!

Pizza here is amazing whenever I come to visit my daughter this is the place to go eat. The pizza was like eating a New York pizza. I can't wait to try their dinners. Go check out Little Italy Pizzeria you won't be disappointed.

We really enjoy this place. The atmosphere is... quaint maybe... It has a hometown feel, with a touch of NY grit. The food is flavorful with homemade touches.

Italian Sub...ask for the big one. Get it cut 1/2. Make two meals or share it on a cheap delicious date! Yummy!!

Love the pizza. But, second time calling ahead for takeout and pizza wasn’t even in the oven when I got here. Don’t tell me how long it will be if you aren’t cooking until I come in. Poor customer service.

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Best Pizza around! Historical now to those of us that have been around Winder a lifetime ~You'll never regret eating here!

Great pizza. So glad I found this place.

Best place for pizza and cheese steak, just like Philly pa

Love this place. Always a hot pizza or hoagie.

Wife had a slice of sausage pizza and I had the stromboli. The stromboli was pretty good, other than I am 95% sure I said "no onions" and there were onions in it. There wasn't enough onions to ruin the stromboli, and I'm 5% unsure if I told them no onions.The pics i took are blurry, sorry folks

Pizza with fresh and good ingredient.

Our pizza is always delicious. The antipasto salad is THE BOMB!

Best pizza ever. We love the atmosphere and sitting by the window watching the people passing on the streets while we have our pizza and salad.

Never had a bad meal here, the food is always fresh and cooked perfect.

Sauce is amazing! Really friendly staff! Got the stromboli, its packed with flavor!

Fantastic pizza, and other Italian dishes. We go here all the time and eat. A little pricey, but worth the money everytime

Had little italy special. Sauce very good, fresh tasting. Meat toppings not greasy.

The food was absolutely delicious and very friendly staff. I always love eating here

I've been here all week for lunch, its great! Good staff, great pizza, and an awesome chef! My go to lunch spot when I'm in town! 👍👍

Great little place! Good food. Very cozy.

Everything came out quickly and tasting wonderful. The staff was so super nice. The game room is an awesome way to entertain the kids while we waited for the food to come out and cool off.

Pizza, pasta, sub sandwiches, calzones, and stromboli, among other things. Friendly customer service and good food. Great place for a family meal. They also have beer and wine, if you want. The salad bar is small and filled with plenty of fresh ingredients.

Great place to eat. Nicole was so attentive and made sure we were happy. Luca, the cook, always does a great job also. Enjoyed the pizza! Salad was great also.

Was passing through town with two hungry kids & I always keep my eye out for a "Authentic Italian" spot or a "Brooklyn Style" slice. So I pass by the sign "Little Italy Pizzeria" and BOOM their store front colors and logo just hits you, kinda gives the you the old neighborhood feeling. I circled around the block and was lucky enough to find parking in front. (There is also parking on the side & in the back). I bring my kids inside and they're screaming for a slice with mootzadell. Great flavor, slices are sized the way they are supposed to be "BIG" I didn't have time to dig deep into the menu, but what we tried was excellent and the atmosphere brought back some good memories.......I definitely recommend it.

The best pizza you can find in this area. Great service

The food was passible. Pretty bland & nothing to write home about. The music being played made us want to leave in a hurry. Didn't go there to go to church. Overall no real reason to go back.

For authentic Italian masterpieces containing the freshest ingredients and an unbelievable tomato sauce, this is your place. I cannot remember eating a more delicious pizza than the ones served here. Brick oven brilliance in downtown Winder.